Shelly Pie Pizza Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Shelly Pie Pizza, located in Turtle Creek, PA, where the vibrant atmosphere and friendly service perfectly complement a diverse, mouthwatering menu. At Shelly Pie, pizza enthusiasts can indulge in both traditional and Sicilian-style pizzas, boasting an extensive array of toppings that promise to satisfy every palate.
- Appetizers: Begin your meal with delightful options like Provolone Sticks or Buffalo Cheese Fries.
- Salads: Enjoy fresh salads, including the generously portioned House Table Salad, ideal for sharing.
- Pizza: Each pie features a delectable combination of perfectly cooked crust, rich sauces, and high-quality toppings that keep patrons returning for more.
With stellar reviews highlighting the quality and flavor of the pizzas, alongside their accommodating staff and cozy environment, Shelly Pie Pizza is a must-visit destination for food lovers.
Appetizers
Fried Appetizers
Salads
Soups
Burgers
Clubs
Hoagies
Sandwiches
Entrees
Traditional Pizza
Sicilian Pizza
Mini Specialties Traditional
Small Specialties Traditional
Medium Specialties Traditional
Large Specialties Traditional
Mini Spec. Sicilian
Small Spec. Sicilian
Large Spec. Sicilian
Gluten Free Pizza
Shellzone
Dough
Appetizer Special
Dinner Specials
Lunch Combo
Salad Specials
Sandwich Special
Soup Bowl Special
Soup Cup Special
NA Beverages
2 Liters
Cans
Quarts / Gallons
Pints
Kids
Desserts
Sides & Extras
Keychain
Appetizers
Banana Peppers Oil & Garlic
$10.50
Bread Sticks
$8.50
Buffalo Cheese Fries
$10.50
Chili Cheese Fries
$10.50
Cinnamon Sugar Knots
$3.50
Parm Garlic Fries
$10.50
Garlic Knots
$3.50
Italian Greens & Beans
$10.25
Pizza Potato Skins
$10.50
Polenta Asiago
$9.99
Pub Pretzels
$9.50
Regular Potato Skins
$10.50
Stuffed Banana Peppers
$10.50
Basket Of Chips
$5.99
Breaded Mushrooms
$7.95
Broccoli Chedder Puffs
$7.95
Chicken Finger Basket
$10.95
Chicken Wings
$9.99
Clam Basket
$10.95
French Fries
$4.25
Fried Pickles
$7.95
Hot Pepper Cheese Balls
$7.95
Onion Rings
$8.50
Provolone Sticks
$8.99
Shrimp Basket
$10.95
Zuchini Planks
$10.75
Basket Of Chips
$5.99
Breaded Mushrooms
$7.95
Broccoli Chedder Puffs
$7.95
Chicken Finger Basket
$10.95
Chicken Wings
$9.99
Clam Basket
$10.95
French Fries
$4.25
Fried Pickles
$7.95
Hot Pepper Cheese Balls
$7.95
Onion Rings
$8.50
Provolone Sticks
$8.99
Shrimp Basket
$10.95
Zuchini Planks
$10.75
Fried Appetizers
Salads
Tossed Salad
$8.49
Family Size Tossed Salad
$18.49
Antipasta Salad
$15.98
Family Sized Antipasta Salad
$23.98
Chef Salad
$15.98
Turkey Club Salad
$15.98
Chicken Salad
$16.49
Steak Salad
$18.74
Wedding Soup
$5.00
Soup Of The Day
$5.00
Chili
$5.00
Soup Flights (Dine In Only)
$10.99
Soups
Burgers
1/2 Pound Burger
$12.25
Maddie Mac
$13.25
Patty Melt
$13.25
American Club
$12.75
Italian Club
$12.75
Turkey & Bacon Club
$12.75
Clubs
Hoagies
Chicken Parm Hoagie
$9.50
Eggplant Parm Hoagie
$9.50
Hot Sausage Hoagie
$9.50
Italian Hoagie
$9.50
Magoo Hoagie
$9.50
Meatball Hoagie
$9.50
Steak Hoagie
$9.50
Turkey Hoagie
$9.50
Veggie Hoagie
$9.50
BLT
$10.99
Chicken Sand
$12.25
Fish Sandwich
$14.25
Grilled Cheese
$8.50
Hot Meatloaf
$12.25
Hot Roast Beef
$12.25
Hot Turkey
$12.25
Rachel
$12.75
Reuben
$12.75
Tuna Melt
$11.99
Sandwiches
Entrees
Cheese Ravioli
$16.25
Chicken Finger Dinner
$16.50
Chicken Marsala
$1.00
Chicken Parmesan
$1.00
Chicken Picatta
$1.00
Eggplant Parmesan
$16.50
Fettuccini Alfredo
$16.25
Gluten Friendly Pasta Marinara
$14.95
Gnocchi
$16.25
Grilled Chicken Breast
$1.00
Lasagna
$18.50
Meatball Parmesan
$16.25
Pasta Arrabiata
$14.95
Pasta Bleu
$18.50
Pasta Bolognese
$15.95
Pasta Marinara
$14.95
Pasta O & G
$14.95
Pasta With Homemade Tomato Sauce
$14.95
Shrimp Scampi
$20.25
Stuffed Shells
$16.25
Mini (4 Cut)
$8.84
Small (6 Cut)
$12.84
Medium (8 Cut)
$14.84
Large (12 Cut)
$16.84
Traditional Pizza
Sicilian Pizza
Sicilian Mini
$8.84
Sicilian Small
$15.35
Sicilian Large
$20.84
Mini Buffalo
$11.59
Mini BBQ
$11.59
Mini Hawaiian
$12.34
Mini EBUT
$19.09
Mini Tom & Spin
$12.34
Mini Special Blue
$16.59
Mini Specialties Traditional
Small Specialties Traditional
Small BBQ Chicken
$15.59
Small Buffalo Chicken
$15.59
Small EBUT
$28.09
Small Hawaiian
$18.34
Small Special Blue
$23.59
Small Tom & Spin
$18.34
Medium BBQ Chicken
$18.09
Medium Buffalo Chicken
$18.09
Medium EBUT
$32.59
Medium Hawaiian
$21.34
Medium Special Bleu
$26.09
Medium Tom & Spin
$21.34
Medium Specialties Traditional
Large Specialties Traditional
Large BBQ Chicken
$20.59
Large Buffalo Chicken
$20.59
Large EBUT
$39.59
Large Hawaiian
$24.34
Large Special Bleu
$29.59
Large Tom & Spin
$24.34
Mini BBQ Chix Sicilian
$10.09
Mini Buffalo Chicken Sicilian
$10.09
Mini EBUT Sicilian
$17.84
Mini Hawaiian Sicilian
$11.84
Mini Special Bleu Sicilian
$14.34
Mini Tom & Spin Sicilian
$11.84
Mini Spec. Sicilian
Small Spec. Sicilian
Small BBQ Chx Sicilian
$17.10
Small Buffalo Chicken Sicilian
$17.10
Small EBUT Sicilian
$26.85
Small Hawaiian Sicilian
$22.35
Small Special Bleu Sicilian
$22.35
Small Tom & Spin Sicilian
$22.35
Large BBQ Chicken Sicilian
$23.09
Large Buffalo Chicken Sicilian
$23.09
Large EBUT Sicilian
$36.09
Large Hawaiian Sicilian
$26.35
Large Special Bleu Sicilian
$29.34
Large Tom & Spin Sicilian
$26.35
Large Spec. Sicilian
Gluten Free Pizza
GLUTEN FREE* Pizza
$13.84
SHELLZONE
$13.50
Shellzone
Dough
Small
$3.85
Medium
$4.85
Large
$5.85
Soup Flight
$10.99
Battered Mac & Cheese
$7.95
Appetizer Special
Dinner Specials
Liver And Onions
$12.99
Philly Cheese Steak Pasta
$15.99
Salmon & Spinach Marsala
$18.99
Chicken Scallopini
$14.99
Spicy Chicken Stack
$14.99
Mini Pizza Combo
$11.59
Mini Meatball & Ricotta
$14.99
Lunch Combo
Salad Specials
Garlic Parm Chicken Salad
$15.49
1/2 Maddie Mac
$12.50
Big Burger
$13.50
Sandwich Special
Soup Bowl Special
Bowl Creamy Italian Sausage
$6.00
Bowl Hot Pepper
$6.00
Cup Creamy Italian Sausage
$5.00
Cup Hot Pepper
$5.00
Soup Cup Special
NA Beverages
16 Oz Bottle
$1.50
20 Oz Bottle
$2.00
24 Oz Bottle
$2.75
Cherry
$3.75
Cherry Coke
$3.75
Coffee
$3.75
Coke
$3.75
Diet Coke
$3.75
Fruit Punch
$3.75
Ginger Ale
$3.75
Hot Choc
$3.75
Hot Tea
$3.75
Iced Tea
$3.75
Pink Lemonade
$3.75
Rasp Iced Tea
$3.75
Root Beer
$3.75
Soda
$1.50
Sprite
$3.75
Water
2 LT MT Dew
$3.50
2 LT Pepsi
$3.50
2 LT Diet Pepsi
$3.50
2 LTCherry Pepsi
$3.50
2 LT Ginger Ale
$3.50
20oz Pepsi
$2.50
24oz Pepsi
$2.75
Bottled Water
$1.00
Can Diet Dew
$1.25
Can Diet Pepsi
$1.25
Can Mt Dew
$1.25
Can Pepsi
$1.25
Red Bull
$3.50
Starbucks Frap
$3.25
Can Dr. Pepper
$1.25
Can Ginger Ale
$1.25
Can Root Beer
$1.25
Gal Diet Iced Tea
$4.00
Gal Reg Iced Tea
$4.00
QRT Black & Gold
$2.00
QRT Diet Iced Tea
$2.00
QRT Reg Iced Tea
$2.00
Lemonade
$1.25
Diet Tea
$1.25
Reg Tea
$1.25
2 LT MT Dew
$3.50
2 LT Pepsi
$3.50
2 LT Diet Pepsi
$3.50
2 LTCherry Pepsi
$3.50
2 LT Ginger Ale
$3.50
2 Liters
Cans
20oz Pepsi
$2.50
24oz Pepsi
$2.75
Bottled Water
$1.00
Can Diet Dew
$1.25
Can Diet Pepsi
$1.25
Can Mt Dew
$1.25
Can Pepsi
$1.25
Red Bull
$3.50
Starbucks Frap
$3.25
Can Dr. Pepper
$1.25
Can Ginger Ale
$1.25
Can Root Beer
$1.25
Gal Diet Iced Tea
$4.00
Gal Reg Iced Tea
$4.00
QRT Black & Gold
$2.00
QRT Diet Iced Tea
$2.00
QRT Reg Iced Tea
$2.00
Quarts / Gallons
Pints
Lemonade
$1.25
Diet Tea
$1.25
Reg Tea
$1.25
Mac & Cheese
$6.50
Kids Chicken Finger
$6.50
Kids Pasta W/ MB
$6.50
Kid Pizza
$6.50
Kids Burger
$6.50
Kids Rav
$6.50
Kids Grilled Cheese
$6.50
Kids
Desserts
Apple Pie
$4.99
Apple Pie Ala Mode
$6.99
Carrot Cake
$7.00
Cheesecake
$8.99
Cherry Pie
$4.99
Cherry Pie Ala Mode
$6.99
Chocolate Fudge Cake
$8.99
Cin Pretzel Bites
$5.99
Funnel Cake Fries
$7.95
Ras. Swirl Cheesecake
$7.99
12 Oz Dressing
$6.49
3 Garlic Bread
$2.50
6 Garlic Bread
$4.50
8 Oz Dressing
$4.99
Apple Sauce
$4.25
Bacon
$2.00
Beef Gravy
$0.65
Cheese Sauce
$1.99
Chicken Gravy
$0.65
Coleslaw
$4.25
Country Gravy
$0.65
Crumbled Bleu
$1.99
Extra Bread
$0.50
Extra Chicken Breast
$5.00
Extra Cocktail
$0.65
Extra Lg Dressing
$2.94
Extra Meat Sauce
$2.00
Extra Meatball
$2.75
Extra Sauce
$0.95
Extra Sausage
$2.75
Extra Sm Dressing
$2.64
Extra Steak
$7.00
Extra Tartar
$0.65
Garlic Butter Lg
$0.95
Garlic Butter Sm
$0.65
Mac & Cheese
$6.50
Mashed
$4.25
Shredded Cheese
$1.99
Side Of Pasta
$6.50
Veg Of Day
$4.25
Quart Of Dressing
$12.98
Sides & Extras
Keychain
Keychain
$5.00